ETS Reform to Protect $12b Revenue by 2035 | Economic News NZ — Economic News
ETS REFORM · FISCAL POLICY
ETS Reform Key to Securing $12 Billion Auction Revenue by 2035
New Zealand risks forgoing $11 billion to $12 billion in Emissions Trading Scheme auction revenue by 2035 without major reforms, according to a Motu Economic and Public Policy Research report released this month.
Cabinet has approved the transfer of any remaining assets and obligations from New Zealand Green Investment Finance to Crown Regional Holdings Limited, New Zealand Growth Capital Partners, Aspire NZ Seed Fund and Treasury.
Inland Revenue will conduct additional stakeholder consultation on proposals to modernise the Goods and Services Tax Act, a 20 November 2026 NBR report confirmed, citing resource constraints that rule out a full rewrite.
The Crown recovered more than $500 million in capital after New Zealand Green Investment Finance Limited completed transfers of its residual assets and obligations on 16 October 2026.
New Zealand risks forgoing $11 billion to $12 billion in Emissions Trading Scheme auction revenue by 2035 without major reforms, according to a Motu Economic and Public Policy Research report released this month.
The report warns that the current ETS design delays gross emissions reductions and creates investment uncertainty. It projects a market glut of forestry-generated units by the mid-2030s that would end the need for government auctions.
This outcome would strip the Crown of a key revenue stream and policy lever. Auction proceeds have totalled $3.8 billion from 2021 through 2025, according to Motu analysis.
All four 2025 auctions and the first three 2026 auctions failed to attract bids. Green Party analysis of Treasury data put the resulting revenue shortfall at $1.4 billion across 2024 to 2026 fiscal years.
Failed auctions increase net core Crown debt, Treasury responses confirm. The shortfalls add pressure to OBEGAL and debt-to-GDP metrics at a time of constrained fiscal headroom.
A watchdog reaches the same conclusion
The Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment reached similar conclusions in its August 2026 report. That document described the ETS as essentially rudderless and at risk of being overwhelmed by forestry unit supply.
Post-1989 pine forests like this one earn NZUs for carbon sequestration under the ETS — a supply Motu and the PCE warn will swamp the market by the mid-2030s.
The Climate Change Commission estimates the current unit surplus at around 30 million NZUs. It projects faster depletion than expected due to the auction failures.
Motu modelling shows that separating forestry removals from the core ETS and funding a distinct removals incentive mechanism could deliver a net fiscal benefit. This approach would support faster gross emissions cuts while preserving auction revenue.
Two different jobs for carbon policy
Catherine Leining of Motu said policy development must start now because the process will take time.
They're actually very different, and New Zealand needs both and the climate needs both
Simon Upton of the PCE argued forestry's role should sit outside the NZ ETS.
Without the use of forestry, we would have no chance of meeting current or future climate targets. But in my view, forestry's role should be outside the NZ ETS.
The government has positioned the ETS as its primary emissions tool. Caretaker Climate Minister Simon Watts highlighted it as the second oldest national scheme in the world during COP31.
A fiscal opportunity, not just a climate fix
Reform offers a fiscal opportunity. It would protect auction income, reduce net debt trajectories, and align settings with emissions budgets that already sit on thin margins.
Treasury forecasts and future Budget updates will reflect any continued auction shortfalls. Officials should begin detailed modelling of separated removals funding without delay.